| Bootle (A) 03/08/19 | Josh Bristow (1) |
| Whitchurch Alport (A) 05/08/19 | Tim Sanders (1) |
| Leicester Road (H) 10/08/19 | Josh Thorpe (1) |
| Litherland Remyca (H) 17/08/19 | Martin Stanyer (1) |
| Winsford Utd (A) 19/08/19 | Joel Stair (1) |
| Eccleshall (A) 31/08/19 | Joel Stair (2) |
| Ashton Athletic (A) 07/09/19 | Josh Thorpe (2) |
| Coventry Sphinx (A) 14/09/19 | Tim Sanders (2) |
| Barnoldswick Town (H) 21/09/19 | Tim Sanders (3) |
| Rylands (H) 28/09/19 | Aaron Woolrich (1) |
| Northwich Victoria (A) 05/10/19 | Josh Thorpe (3) |
| AFC Mansfield (A) 12/10/19 | James Phillips (1) |
| 1874 Northwich (A) 15/10/19 | Jake Alcock (1) |
| Squires Gate (A) 29/10/19 | Mick Morton (1) |
| Longridge Town (A) 21/12/19 | Aaron Woolrich (2) |
| Congleton Town (H) 26/12/19 | Oli Mellor (1) |
| Northwich Victoria (H) 04/01/20 | Aaron Woolrich (3) |
| Runcorn Town (A) 12/02/20 | Whole Team |