| Rank | Player | Club | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aaron Woolrich (GK) | - | |
| 2 | Tim Sanders | Hanley Town | |
| 3 | Josh Bristow * | Hanley Town | |
| 4 | Josh Beaumont | Hanley Town | |
| 5 | Josh Thorpe | Hanley Town | |
| 6 | Jake Vernon | Hanley Town | |
| 7 | Tom Ashton | Hanley Town | |
| 8 | Dean Smith | Hanley Town | |
| 9 | Chris Boast | Hanley Town | |
| 10 | Chris Budrys | Hanley Town | |
| 11 | Jon Sheldon | Hanley Town | |
| 12 | Jon Birks | Hanley Town | |
| 13 | Jake Alcock | Hanley Town | |
| 14 | Martin Stanyer | Hanley Town | |
| 15 | Oliver Mellor | Hanley Town | |
| 16 | Gareth Stanyer | Hanley Town | |
| 17 | Nev Thompson | Hanley Town | |
| 18 | Lewis Doughty | Hanley Town | |
| 19 | Serkari Ahmadi | Hanley Town | |
| 20 | Florin Balajel | Hanley Town | |
| 21 | Tim Barrass | Hanley Town | |
| 22 | Lewis Bergin | Hanley Town | |
| 23 | Kallum Boyle | Hanley Town | |
| 24 | Niall Cope | Hanley Town | |
| 25 | Ben Cortes-Smith | Hanley Town | |
| 26 | Jordan Darlington | Hanley Town | |
| 27 | Harry Goode | Hanley Town | |
| 28 | Jordan Hall | Hanley Town | |
| 29 | Jon Higham | Hanley Town | |
| 30 | Dane Jackson | Hanley Town | |
| 31 | Jon Kapend | Hanley Town | |
| 32 | Alex Langridge | Hanley Town | |
| 33 | Mick Morton | Hanley Town | |
| 34 | James Phillips | Hanley Town | |
| 35 | Oliver Putnam | Hanley Town | |
| 36 | Daniel Read | Hanley Town | |
| 37 | Tom Riley | Hanley Town | |
| 38 | Joel Stair | Hanley Town | |
| 39 | Theo Stair | Hanley Town | |
| 40 | Rhys Thompson | Hanley Town | |
| 41 | Sean Turner | Hanley Town | |
| 42 | Peter Williams | Hanley Town | |
| 43 | Mackenzie Faulkner | Hanley Town | |
| 44 | Tom Winkle | Hanley Town | |
| 45 | Ethan Cartwright | Hanley Town | |
| 46 | James Melhado | Hanley Town | |
| 47 | Michael Edwards | Hanley Town | |
| 48 | Daniel Needham | Hanley Town | |
| 49 | David MacPherson | Hanley Town | |
| 50 | Dominic Kurasik | Hanley Town | |
| 51 | Ethan Hartshorn | Hanley Town | |
| 52 | Mitchell Glover | Hanley Town | |
| 53 | Matthew Ball | Hanley Town | |
| 54 | Tommy Van Der Laan | Hanley Town | |
| 55 | Dan Cope | Hanley Town | |
| 56 | James Pointon | Hanley Town | |
| 57 | Leigh Skellern | Hanley Town | |
| 58 | Danny Tainton | Hanley Town | |
| 59 | Mick Machin | Hanley Town | |
| 60 | Angelo Errico | Hanley Town | |
| 61 | Sean Mountford | Hanley Town | |
| 62 | Jamie Turner | Hanley Town | |
| 63 | Olly Edwards | Hanley Town | |
| 64 | Ben Blowers | Hanley Town | |
| 65 | Michael Conlon | Hanley Town | |
| 66 | Nathan Grice | Hanley Town | |
| 67 | Karl Miller | Hanley Town | |
| 68 | Curtis Price | Hanley Town | |
| 69 | Josh Hall | Hanley Town | |
| 70 | Nick Ward | Hanley Town | |
| 71 | Andy Nicholls | Hanley Town | |
| 72 | Keiron Ball | Hanley Town | |
| 73 | Ben Lees | Hanley Town | |
| 74 | Dwayne Spence | Hanley Town | |
| 75 | Lassana Sidebe | Hanley Town | |
| 76 | Mark Groom | Hanley Town | |
| 77 | Jamie Skellern | Hanley Town | |
| 78 | Taylor Attrell | Hanley Town | |
| 79 | Matt German | Hanley Town | |
| 80 | Daniel Shelley | Hanley Town | |
| 81 | Kartel O’Neil-Martin | Hanley Town | |
| 82 | Michael Keates | Hanley Town | |
| 83 | Lewis Grocott | Hanley Town | |
| 84 | Nathan Jones | Hanley Town Reserves | |
| 85 | Phil Parkes | Hanley Town | |
| 86 | Sean Mallin | Hanley Town | |
| 87 | Curtis Evans | Hanley Town | |
| 88 | Nathan Chinn Shaw | Hanley Town | |
| 89 | Arron Johns | Hanley Town | |
| 90 | Gareth Tweats | Hanley Town | |
| 91 | Joe Donaldson | Hanley Town | |
| 92 | Callum Tunstall | Hanley Town | |
| 93 | James Lindop | Hanley Town | |
| 94 | Lewis Salmon | Hanley Town | |
| 95 | Richie Shankland | Hanley Town | |
| 96 | Jon Barrass | Hanley Town | |
| 97 | Dan Hughes | Hanley Town | |
| 98 | Matt Bell | Hanley Town | |
| 99 | Jack Watson | Hanley Town | |
| 100 | Ben Rowley | Hanley Town | |
| 101 | Ryan Dicker | Hanley Town | |
| 102 | Sam Hati | Hanley Town | |
| 103 | George Mealey | Hanley Town | |
| 104 | Lee Wilshaw | Hanley Town | |
| 105 | Doug Price | Hanley Town | |
| 106 | Charlie Goldstraw | Hanley Town | |
| 107 | Dave Harry | Hanley Town | |
| 108 | Warren Holmes | Hanley Town | |
| 109 | Nathan Okome | Hanley Town | |
| 110 | Joe Thompson | Hanley Town | |
| 111 | George Woodroffe * | Hanley Town | |
| 112 | Kieran Brown | Hanley Town | |
| 113 | Kieron Williams | Hanley Town | |
| 114 | Ben Chapman (GK) | Hanley Town | |
| 115 | Adam Lawrence (GK) | Hanley Town | |
| 116 | Callum Feeney | Hanley Town | |
| 117 | Brian Barton | Hanley Town | |
| 118 | Jake Langdridge | Hanley Town | |
| 119 | Kyle Stubbs | Hanley Town | |
| 120 | Luke Lewis * | Hanley Town | |
| 121 | Tyler Savage | Hanley Town | |
| 122 | Ricardo Fuller | Hanley Town | |
| 123 | Louis Anthony | Hanley Town | |
| 124 | Ryanjay Malbon * | Hanley Town | |
| 125 | Charlie Walford | Hanley Town | |
| 126 | Semi Wara | Hanley Town |
| Bootle (A) 03/08/19 | Josh Bristow (1) |
| Whitchurch Alport (A) 05/08/19 | Tim Sanders (1) |
| Leicester Road (H) 10/08/19 | Josh Thorpe (1) |
| Litherland Remyca (H) 17/08/19 | Martin Stanyer (1) |
| Winsford Utd (A) 19/08/19 | Joel Stair (1) |
| Eccleshall (A) 31/08/19 | Joel Stair (2) |
| Ashton Athletic (A) 07/09/19 | Josh Thorpe (2) |
| Coventry Sphinx (A) 14/09/19 | Tim Sanders (2) |
| Barnoldswick Town (H) 21/09/19 | Tim Sanders (3) |
| Rylands (H) 28/09/19 | Aaron Woolrich (1) |
| Northwich Victoria (A) 05/10/19 | Josh Thorpe (3) |
| AFC Mansfield (A) 12/10/19 | James Phillips (1) |
| 1874 Northwich (A) 15/10/19 | Jake Alcock (1) |
| Squires Gate (A) 29/10/19 | Mick Morton (1) |
| Longridge Town (A) 21/12/19 | Aaron Woolrich (2) |
| Congleton Town (H) 26/12/19 | Oli Mellor (1) |
| Northwich Victoria (H) 04/01/20 | Aaron Woolrich (3) |
| Runcorn Town (A) 12/02/20 | Whole Team |